Plain. Black. Tights: The Best and the Worst.

Plain black tights. A British girls wardrobe staple for any occasion. My life long dream is to pull a pair of tights out of my drawer which don’t have a hole of some form in them. I’ve tried all brands in all shapes and all sizes. So here is my brief round up of the best (and worst) opaque black tights on the block. Things to bear in mind in this post when it comes to sizing/longevity is that I am a size 10-12 on the bottom and wear them EVERY GOD DAMN DAY (obviously alternating pairs). Don’t worry, the ‘reviews’ are pretty brief, as let’s face it, expanding on black tights is pushing the boundaries of interesting content, even for me. These reviews are of predominantly supermarket brands, as buying tights for some comes as often as buying bread. Well, for me it does anyway.
Plain. Black. Tights: The Best and the Worst on Hello Terri Lowe, fashion blog.

3 pack 80 Denier Tights £5 in S/M.
Fit: Fairly comfortable although the waistband tends to come up a little high (over belly button height if you pull them up far enough!). Tend to come in slightly bigger than you’d expect from a small to medium tight and can boarder on a little loose depending on how much bread you’ve eaten that day.

Quality: Good. They appear to be a nice silky finish without a horrid shine on.

Longevity: Unfortunately after around 2 weeks holes begin appearing around the seam near your lady parts. But they’re fairly robust overall and don’t ladder easily.

Overall: 8/10

3 pack 40 Denier Tights £4 in S/M
Fit: Once again, fairly comfortable. The waistband seems to come in a little lower than the aforementioned 80 denier option, but with the same issues of being a little bigger when you’re less bloated.

Quality: Weird. They come across almost ‘bitty’? Not a smooth finish but still relatively opaque for 40 denier.

Longevity: Just keep these away from velcro and cats. The holes come easily and expand at a rapid pace when you try and pull them up. They don’t ladder down, but across.

Overall: 6/10


3 pack 40 Denier Tights £3.50 in S/M
Fit:  Ok, nothing to complain about, but the waistband does tend to come up very high on me. The seam around your crotch seems to be a bit… tight/thick… I dunno. Like sometimes if you’re over zealous pulling them up – you feel it. Ha.
Quality:  As high as you’d expect from Primark. I basically buy these for ’emergency tights’ now, but find they are a slightly ‘smoother’ finish than the Asda 40 denier tights.

Longevity: Once again, as you’d expect – not super long. After around 3 weeks the holes in the butt start to appear and they stretch out of shape a little.

Overall: 5/10

*I was also going to mention the Super Cosy tights from Primark, but will just stick to the fact that after I’ve worn mine around 4 times they stretch totally out of shape.


Fit: Perfect height around the hips! Hurrah!! True to size and comfortable.

Quality: Very nice and smooth without a shiny finish. Although I’m debating the 60 denier finish as the ‘weave'(?) seems slightly more spaced than usual. I don’t know how to explain that one.

Longevity: I can’t actually comment on this yet, as I literally bought them on my lunch break after a pair of Sainsbury’s tights failed me with a MASSIVE hole on my thigh – not the best look for work. But so far, so good!

Overall: 9/10 (so far)


Fit:  Last time I bought these they were MASSIVE. Way too long and gave a right good Nora Batty wrinkle around the ankle, no matter how high I pulled them up. They’re basically a bra and tights in one with extra ankle space.

Quality: I didn’t like these at all. They were too fine for a 60 denier, and seemed more like a 40. Perhaps packaged in the wrong packaging? Who knows. And when combined with the constant need to pull them up, holes appear really quickly.

Longevity: Like, a week?

Overall: 3/10 


Fit: Came up high, like most, but the sizing was true enough for a S/M pair of tights.

Quality: An easy to rip/snag finish with a slightly shiny sheen. They felt and looked cheap.

Longevity: Like the Tesco ones; about a week. Holes developed in the seam around your crotch after about the 2nd wear! Maybe it’s the fact I thought Sainsburys would naturally be better quality than most. But no.

Overall: 2/10

So there we have it, brief reviews of some tights. Doesn’t get more exciting than that really does it? Should I ask where you have found the best tights? Let me know below!
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Mrs C

I know this is an older post but I just found this now. I tried marks and spencer, falke, wolford, sainsbury's, Superdrugs, Primark and wolford. I'd say price value.and longevity go for m&s. For quality,feel but less for price wolford. Loved your article

Mirror Trigger

The best black tights ( I also wear them every single day of my life) are the 300 deniers from asda. £4 a pair. They never rip or get ladders. I wear them inside out and they're totally matte.


This is actually one of the most useful posts ever! Don't spose you have any opinions on nude/skin-colour ones, do ya? I bought some Superdrug ones not long ago, and they were all well and good fit-wise, but so shiny I need ski goggles to look at them. How I missed that in the store god alone knows.

Nora Mc

I’m telling you M & S for tights. Only way forward!!

Amy Keeling

This was a great idea, tights are a staple in my wardrobe too! The Primark Cosy ones are initially really nice however mine bobbled up like crazy making them so unsightly…I wasn't impressed. I know Peacocks have a similar pair but as of yet I haven't tried them, there isn't much need for them yet either but I may pick some up for autumn.
Amy x | A Little Boat Sailing

Helen Smith

This is sooo useful! Tights and I just do not get on at the best of times so it's great to be able to know which ones might have a little more staying power! Hurrahhhh!!!!


Melissa Bakhsh

As a person who wears 2 pairs of 80 denier black tights each and every bloomin' day – this is the most relevant blog post I've ever read.
(I need help)

Anyways, ever tried the Tesco 80 denier? They do a £4 and a £6 pack with two pairs in each. You get a reinforced gusset with the six quid pairs apparently. And who doesn't love one of them?

I'm going to hit up M&S as well though. Join the gang and all that!


M&S do my favourite opaque black tights. A pack of 3 pairs is £8 (they're the 60 denier BodySensor ones) which seems a bit pricey but they last amazingly well! Holes only seem to appear after a good few months, they wash well and fit really nicely. Worth the splurge for me! x

Kirsty W

Have to agree! I'm a total cheapskate so avoided M&S for ages but they're so much better than any others. Plus Primark tights aren't actually cheap when you're buying them every week haha

deltrey Lemba David

Très joli look!